On your choices Toast...depends on what you wanna do.
If you wanna cruise around with nice control go for the first one, although the handling depends greatly on the trucks and what kind of bushings they come with, not the board.
*edit: Ok...the length and the width of a board do matter, but so does the width of the trucks, and the wheels...and the bushings...and blah blah blah.
If you wanna carve around and stuff go with the second one. It's an old school shape. I got one of the more famous ones laying around in my room lol.